The story behind “Sacrificial Lambs”

As you know, almost all of the songs we write tell stories. We want to share those stories with you.  Just as we did for the songs on our first CD 13, we’ll post the story behind each song on our new CD Again here for you to read. The plan is to feature one song each week for the next 11 weeks.

Here is the story behind Sacrificial Lambs as related by Gary McGraw.

From our new CD Again

The song “Sacrificial Lambs”

Sacrifical Lambs is the first song I have ever written. Though I have recorded lots of original music, written plenty of musical hooks, and re-arranged many songs in collaboration, before Sacrificial Lambs I had never created a song of my own from scratch.

Sacrificial Lambs is one of two songs on Again driven by the shock of the Newtown massacre. After a Florida-art-trip–related hiatus, we came together for musica one evening and both Clark and I had new songs to share. This is the one I brought.

I remember sitting in my car in downtown Berryville when the idea struck: why is it that Abraham’s son Isaac was spared sacrifice (at the last minute no less) while the 26 children shot to death in Newtown were not? That’s the simple but very hard question behind the lyrics.

The first verse is set on a mountain top in the Old Testament and, as the story goes, shows the merciful god interposing on Isaac’s sacrifice at the last second. The next verse is about gun-related terror in a modern kindergarten classroom just before Christmas. Then comes the hard question asked directly of a god who failed to intervene and left us in a situation with “Walmart guns and rent-a-cops in every school.”

Musically, the main hook of the song is lifted directly from the opening theme of Rachmaninoff’s Third Piano Concerto—a simple melody that has haunted me since I was very young. I sometimes wish I could play the piano just so I could play that concerto. My grandfather was a trained concert pianist who debuted with the New York Philharmonic in Carnegie Hall when he was 12. Then he broke his wrists playing football and lost too much dexterity to continue. I am told that when I was very young he would play the third on our upright to impress our teenage babysitters. That must be why the haunting melody of the theme is so deep inside me.

Once I had the lyrics and the theme cobbled together, Allen helped me properly assemble everything and find the right drive. It’s a privilege to learn from a master.

Every time we’ve performed this song it makes someone in the audience cry. Maybe it’s a good thing that it took me 47 years to write my first song.

Gary McGraw

Read the lyrics to Sacrificial Lambs.
Learn the story behind Worry Me No More
Learn the story behind Sacrificial Lambs

6 thoughts on “The story behind “Sacrificial Lambs”

  1. Pingback: The story behind “Worry Me No More” | The Bitter Liberals

  2. Gary
    That’s a really good post. It’s really interesting to read these posts about the genesis of these songs, because it’s often hard to know the real story just from listening.
    I really like the message of the song.
    I have a lot of questions for ” the Man” too….
    All the best to the band…George

    • Thanks George. We’re glad these stories behind the song resonate with our listeners. Sometimes we learn things about songs ourselves from reading these stories (even though we have played them a million times).

  3. Pingback: The story behind “Bright Penny” | The Bitter Liberals

  4. Pingback: All of the stories behind Again (the record) | The Bitter Liberals

  5. Pingback: Stories, stories, stories | The Bitter Liberals

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: